Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Tia Ja'nae's avatar

No the actual creatives are not getting “over it”. AI isn’t like inventing the cotton gin. It’s flat out stealing work from everybody in the fine arts and making those styles/formats “accessible” like they’re some twisted version of Mad Libs so everybody can feel “creative”.

The Painters/Sketchers/Inkers are mad. The Musicians are mad. The Writers are mad. The film folks are mad. Theater people are mad. There’s a reason for that, but I’m going to keep this just to literature since this is Substack.

More and more writers like you are crossing their moral line and giving in to AI, writing OpEds on why its “okay” to use it and over explaining it away as to how they are “short on time” or “it helps them get ideas and helps them not to suffer the process of creation”. It’s BULLSHIT. All I’m getting from this is, people who have no idea how to write, who don’t care to learn the art of storytelling, finally have a cheat that allows them to be “a writer” and compete with people that are actually doing the fucking work without it, and have been.

Make yourself obsolete engaging in the thing created to replace you, but you’re not getting every writer’s support on that. Nothing CAN BE COPYRIGHTED made with AI. So all your stuff is instant public domain.

Then there’s the devil in the details that AI literally steals work from people WITHOUT compensating the person who actually did said work. Sure, argue about that settlement from ZUCKERBERG STEALING 9 million pirated books to feed into his AI. It’s all bullshit. FBI didn’t come drag his ass out by the ankles and haul his ass off to jail for the theft. Nor is the settlement fair and just. They are using all types of backdoors not to pay the authors, including saying "oh, well some of the authors didn't file for copyright". Only in America do you have a copyright office where you have to pay for copyright. The rest of the world it's copywritten the minute you put it down on paper. No one has a "copyright office" but America. It's all bullshit.

That little tidbit is also how Amazon is stealing people's works too.

Oh, and then there’s this pesky little item about oversaturation that will surely bite you in the ass as well.

https://www.theguardian.com/books/2024/nov/26/writers-condemn-startups-plans-to-publish-8000-books-next-year-using-ai-spines-artificial-intelligence

So go ahead, yell that we’re overreacting but when your time comes on the chopping block to be eliminated, remember your mantra here.

https://articul8madness.substack.com/p/ai-is-the-sum-of-all-things-automation

Christine Whitmarsh's avatar

Holy crap Cookie, you hit this one out of the f’ing park, especially from a psych perspective!

So yeah, lots of people stuck in this old cognitive cycle but with just a helluva lot more reinforcement and societal support to stay stuck:

1) Hear about a new thing

2) Have a kneejerk emotional reaction to thing for whatever personal reason based on existing beliefs, past experiences, combination thereof, pick your favorite foundational elements of confirmation bias.

3) Form a new belief (aka “fact”).

4) Build walls of cherry picked “evidence” around said belief - like Fort Knox in this case.

5) Pew-pew-pew any conflicting beliefs or evidence that might threaten said belief.

6) Ta-dah! The fort becomes a lovely new cognitive dream home. (Pew pew pew to keep the scary things out.)

404 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?